Thursday, January 24, 2013

The Road vs The Walking Dead

The Road and The Walking Dead both fall into the category of post-apocalyptic stories focused around a small group survivors pitted against the horrors of a new world. These horrors can come literally in the physical form with zombies and cannibals; or from the struggle to find shelter and futility that comes from knowing that you can never truly rebuild civilization. Despite The Road being almost entirely literary in nature, and The Waling Dead leaning more towards commercialism, the two works can still be compared to see how certain elements from both of them overlap or stand alone.
 

The time period of the two works is never explicitly stated, but it is assumed they are in the foreseeable future. The Road is set against a bleak, infinitely grey backdrop, that resulted from some unknown natural disaster. The Walking Dead retains the beauty of the natural world at the expense of it being overrun by droves of zombies. Both are set in the American southeast. These two distinct settings provide for some of the key differences between The Road and The Walking Dead. The increasingly cold and hostile surroundings of the boy and the man require them to move towards the coast in hopes of warmer temperatures. However, they have little food and aren't even sure that the coast will provide the refuge that they desperately need. They are surrounded by the unseen enemy of nature, time, a limited food supply, and sects of cannibals stalking the land. There is always a slight undertone of futility in McCarthy's writing. He wants the audience to understand that even if the two reach the coast, life will most likely not improve for them. Having this constant sense of hopelessness contributes to the tone  while also making it evident that all the characters actions are most likely in vain. I felt this even at the end when the boy decides to continue with the veteran's group. I thought it was a relatively happy ending, but then I realized that they be lucky forever and keep finding countless supplies of food. This is almost never seen in The Walking Dead. Watching The Walking Dead, I never feel a sense of urgency or that everything may go wrong for all the characters. It's a great show and I love it, I just never feel scared for the characters like I do when reading The Road. I always know that despite what happens, most of the major characters in The Walking Dead will end up surviving any conflict. I think that the creators of The Walking Dead wanted to instill a sense of hope in their audience. The world may be overrun by zombies, but it isn't covered in permanent cloud of grey ash that has destroyed the natural world and left little possible hope for rebirth. Their is still a possibility that Rick and his group could establish a commune free from zombies, similar to what the Governor has. Some characters may die, but you always know that everything will be ok for the majority of the group. 

It may not have be fair to compare a novel to a TV show. The Walking Dead is more commercial which means the audience will want a happy ending. Whereas The Road is literary and can be as pessimistic and depressing as it wants.  The Road could have only been so long, but The Walking Dead can go on for as long as people continue to watch. This allows for more room for hope and rebirth since a show entirely about how depressingly awful life has become would not last long. However, not even Cormac McCarthy with all his prowess could create a character as developed and advanced as the lustrous T-Dog. 

No comments:

Post a Comment